Connecting the dots
One evening I found myself thinking about something we use every single day without ever really asking what it is: money. The longer I sat with it, the stranger and more interesting it got. Here's the small thought experiment that started it.
Suppose there is only one $20 bill in an isolated town, and Alice has it.
- Alice pays Bob $20 to fix her bike.
- Bob spends the same $20 at Carol's grocery store.
- Carol pays David $20 to mow her lawn.
- David pays Alice $20 for dinner.
By noon:
Did anyone cheat? No.
The important part is that money isn't used up when it's spent. It's less like fuel and more like a token that records ownership as it passes from hand to hand.
The bike repair still exists. The groceries were delivered. The lawn was mowed. The dinner was eaten. Four real, physical things happened in this town that can't be undone, and one $20 bill simply changed owners four times to make them happen.
Spending doesn't destroy money, it moves it
Think about buying a painting for $100. From where you stand, the $100 is gone. But it hasn't vanished from the world. It's sitting in the seller's pocket, ready to be spent again. What you gave up wasn't the money itself but your claim on everything else that $100 could have bought. In exchange, you got the painting.
That's what money really is: a claim. It's the power to call on someone else's goods, time or work. So the true value of money isn't the number printed on it. It's what it can buy, right now. Economists call this purchasing power.
A dollar today isn't a dollar tomorrow
Here's where it gets more interesting. Say you're selling something for $100, and two buyers show up. One will pay $100 in cash today. The other wants it now but will pay you $100 a year from now.
Would you treat them the same? Almost certainly not, and for at least three reasons:
- Opportunity: $100 in your hand today can be put to work. Even in a plain savings account at, say, 5%, it becomes $105 in a year. Waiting means giving that up.
- Risk: A year is a long time. The buyer could lose their job, move away or simply not pay.
- Inflation: Even if they do pay, $100 next year will probably buy a little less than $100 buys today.
Now suppose the second buyer comes back with a better offer: “I'll pay you in a year, but I'll pay $150.” Suddenly the choice isn't obvious. If your money could only earn about 5% elsewhere, a 50% reward for waiting is very generous. You might even prefer this buyer to the one paying cash, as long as you trust them to pay.
Without meaning to, you've just priced time and trust. That's exactly what an interest rate is. Every loan, mortgage and bond is a version of this same choice between money now and more money later.
And if you've ever wondered where new money comes from, or whether money itself can grow, Where Does Money Come From? is where you should head next.
So, what is money, really, for you?
Economists have names for both ideas in this piece. How many times the same dollar changes hands in a given period is the velocity of money. The idea that a dollar's value depends on when you have it is the time value of money. Both are small pieces of a much bigger question about what money actually represents, which I'll keep sitting with.
More about who's writing this is on the About page. If this got you thinking, or you'd push back on any of it, I'd genuinely love to hear it: sharma.rujjwal [at] gmail [dot] com. Want a note when something new goes up? Say so in your email and I'll add you to the list.