Rujjwal's Notebook

Time begins with movement

Particles, perception, and an epiphany about what time actually is.

Maya, about consciousness

I once had an epiphany about time: a brief moment when it felt like I understood it. It was more an experience of understanding than a framework. Without real expertise in math or physics, I'm not sure my understanding would stand up to that test. Still, I want to write it down, so that I, and anyone who finds some value here, can use it as a thread to add to our own imagining of nature, time and reality. Here is how I try to piece it together.

No motion, no time

Space is a requisite for motion, and motion is a requisite for time. Time exists wherever there is a particle or mass, wherever there is movement: vibration, angular momentum, motion of any kind. Time begins with that movement, and it ceases when all movement ceases.

In a way, time is a measure of movement. It measures change, process, evolution. If there were no motion, what would time measure? Even we humans need motion to measure time: the hands of a clock, or the vibrations inside the atoms of an atomic clock. I'm not sure how other living beings keep track of time. It certainly isn't with a clock, but I suspect they are tracking some kind of motion too, whether an internal circadian rhythm or the external cycles of the sun, the moon and the seasons.

The motion that time needs is not only the physical motion we can see. It includes thought and perception, subatomic vibrations, and the intrinsic motion inside particles themselves. When there is no change and no motion, time seems to freeze, and it restarts when movement begins again.

A frozen man

Think about a man who died at 60 of an incurable disease and was cryogenically frozen. Suppose that in the future we have the technology to revive him, and he is thawed back to life after 100 years. How old is he: 60 or 160?

I'm sure a part of you will say 60. He was frozen. Even in that deep cold, a trace of motion remains, since nothing in nature is ever perfectly still. But for all practical purposes he was motionless: no life spent, no passage of time for him. Biologically, he has barely aged past the moment he was frozen, because motion at the cellular level came almost to a standstill and his cellular clock all but froze. Nor did he gain the wisdom he would have gained had he actually lived to 160. So time was different for him than for us, in the same world. He lived 60 years within a span of 160.

Where time begins

If time needs movement, then time must have begun with the very first movement. I guess that's why it's said that time began with the Big Bang, and that there was no time before it. In our universe, or at least in the substance we are made of and under the laws by which it was created and functions, the first movement happened at the moment of the Big Bang. With that first movement, there was finally something for time to measure, and every movement since has been counted from it. That's why here we are, 13.8 billion years later.

Where time seems to stop

Since that first moment, nothing in the universe has moved faster than light. Light, a stream of photons, travels at the universe's speed limit. For light, leaving a star and arriving in your eye happen in the same instant, even if the journey took a million years by our clocks.

Anything with mass can never reach that speed. The faster it goes, the more energy it takes to push it further, without limit, and the slower its clock runs compared to ours. Only things with no mass at all, like the photon, travel at the speed of light, and only they experience no time. Mass and time seem to go together. Einstein's famous equation, E=mc², tells us that mass is a form of energy, and when matter meets antimatter, its mass is converted entirely into light. In that instant, something that had a clock becomes something that doesn't. When mass vanishes into energy, time, for that energy, vanishes too.

Light is the fastest motion there is, yet the photon itself experiences no time at all. But for everyone else watching that photon, there is time. It measures the event of the light leaving the star and landing in your eye, and everything in between.

Where time ends

Now think about the far end. Stars burn out and galaxies go dark. The black holes left behind won't last forever either. One by one, over unimaginable stretches of time, they slowly evaporate, giving off their mass as Hawking radiation until they vanish. When the last of them is gone, and the remaining particles have drifted so far apart that a hundred light-years separate any two atoms, will time still be relevant? Who would measure it, and what would be its purpose?

Motion would probably never reach exactly zero; physics says a faint quantum jitter always remains. But nothing would change in any meaningful way. As far as my meager brain can see, time will have practically ceased long before that point. Exactly when, or why, I simply can't say.

I'm not alone in this thought. The physicist Roger Penrose has proposed something strikingly similar. In his idea, called Conformal Cyclic Cosmology, once only light and other massless particles remain, nothing is left that can act as a clock, so time loses its meaning altogether. And that vast, empty universe could become the Big Bang of the next one.

When things get this deep, I want to add a LOL, to remind myself how tiny we are on the scale of the cosmos, and how tiny our understanding and our capacity to understand this infinite vastness are. And yet, we do.

Space without time

Space, I think, can exist without time. In a scenario like the one above, when the universe's entropy is so high and its temperature so low that motion is virtually absent, time will cease. But space, once created, will likely remain.

I should admit this is where I part ways with mainstream physics. Since Einstein, space and time have been treated as a single fabric, spacetime, which bends around anything with mass; that bending is what we feel as gravity. Near a black hole, where mass is packed to extreme density, spacetime bends so sharply that clocks slow almost to a stop. The standard view is also that space and time began together at the Big Bang. So my idea that space can outlive time is the contrarian part of this piece. I hold it as an intuition, not a claim I can prove.

Still, I picture it this way. Perhaps space will remain as an opportunity for magic to happen: for a subatomic particle to emerge randomly, literally out of nothing, and create a motion, beginning another perpetual journey of time that spirals into who knows what. For anyone who hasn't come across this, it isn't just fantasy. Physics tells us that empty space is never truly empty: pairs of subatomic particles flicker into existence out of the vacuum and vanish back into it all the time. That magic is woven into the fabric of our universe. We just don't get to appreciate it day to day, but our cosmos is far more magical than our imaginations can take us. Perhaps, after another tens of billions of years, a start from such random motion will lead to the emergence of life, and of a consciousness that ponders the nature of time and space, just as I'm doing right now.

Someone might ask: doesn't a particle need time in order to emerge? I don't think so. Like the Big Bang, that emergence isn't an event that happens inside time. It is the event that starts time. Time doesn't wait for the first movement; it begins with it.

But time cannot exist without space. Movement happens in space, and it is that movement which gives rise to time. So time comes woven into space from the very beginning. It starts with the first movement in that space, with the emergence of the first particle. It is built into the intrinsic vibrations of particles at the smallest scale, and into every movement at the largest scale too. Time likely has no existence outside of space, and no meaning without motion.

Time within our mind

This logic may have something to do with what yogis describe: when thoughts stop arising in a deep meditative state, you experience a sense of timelessness. The clock on the wall keeps ticking and the heart keeps beating, so physical time doesn't stop. But felt time does. Felt time follows the motion of the mind, the way physical time follows the motion of matter. When the mind's movement goes still, its time goes still too. It's the same principle, turned inward.

Our bodies and minds are made of the same fundamental particles as the rest of the universe, so it doesn't surprise me that the same rule seems to show up inside us. For a subject as elusive as time, a great mystery to physicists and philosophers alike, turning inward and practicing meditation may offer an experiential way of knowing it. That may also relate to the transcendental states and other states of consciousness people reach through meditation and yogic practice.

No change, no time. Space can exist without time, but time cannot exist without space.

This is my own way of thinking about time, shaped by ideas from physics I find beautiful, not a formal physics paper. I'd love to hear how it lands with you, and where you'd push back.

More about who's writing this is on the About page. If this got you thinking, or you'd push back on any of it, I'd genuinely love to hear it: sharma.rujjwal [at] gmail [dot] com. Want a note when something new goes up? Say so in your email and I'll add you to the list.