Rujjwal's Notebook

The only life we ever live

Is one choice really better than the other?

Maya, about consciousness

I remember, after college, feeling like I was standing at a fork in the road that would decide the course of my life. I had to choose what I would study, and that would decide my career. After failing to secure a full scholarship to medical school, I was in despair. The choice between paying partial tuition for medical school and joining an engineering school on a full scholarship was a huge decision for me. One did not sit well with me financially; the other was not the career I had envisioned for myself. For a brief period, my relationship with my family and my girlfriend was strained by the stress I was going through and how it showed in my behavior. In the end, I decided to pay the tuition and join medical school, but with a heavy heart: a sense of failure for not securing the scholarship, a big bag of financial burden, and an imagined future of doing well in engineering with no loans at all.

That was about 18 years ago, and when I look back at that moment, I often wonder whether I made the right decision. I’m financially stable now, I have no loans or big financial burden, and I’m happy with my work and pay overall. Am I happy because my life has worked out so far, or because I avoided some disaster by not choosing engineering? It’s probably the former, not the latter, because I really can’t tell whether I would have been a success or a failure as an engineer. Whatever I tell myself is only imagination, and depending on how I feel, I can paint one imagined life better than the other. Moreover, you cannot compare a reality with an imagination. And at that moment, both options were imagination for me: two imagined futures, with equal uncertainty. The choice I arrived at was definitely not because I had seen myself 18 years into the future.

In our lives, some paths may be better than others, and some choices may deserve to be preferred. But no imagined future is worth pursuing so fiercely that we sacrifice our judgment, our integrity, or the peace of our present life.

The lives we only imagine

There are countless lives we might have lived, but only one we ever will. We tend to overestimate the difference between the path we chose and the paths we did not, because we can imagine those alternatives but never actually experience them.

The imagined life never has bad days. It never has a difficult boss, a long winter, or a Tuesday where nothing goes right. We compare our real life, with all its texture, to another life that exists only as a highlight reel.

It turns out psychologists have been studying this for decades. Affective forecasting is our ability to predict how a choice will make us feel, and Daniel Gilbert and Timothy Wilson have shown that we are consistently bad at it. We expect a good outcome to lift us higher, and a bad one to sink us lower and for longer, than it actually does.1

One small experiment stays with me. Gilbert and Jane Ebert had students in a photography course print their two favorite photos and keep only one. Some were told the choice was final. Others were told they could swap it within a few days. You would expect the second group to be happier; they had a way out. They weren’t. The students who could still change their minds liked their photo less. The ones who couldn’t simply settled in and grew fond of what they had. And yet, when asked beforehand, most people said they would rather keep the option open.2

Another of their studies followed young professors waiting to hear whether they would get tenure, the decision that makes or breaks an academic career. Those still waiting predicted that being turned down would leave them unhappy for years. But when the researchers checked on professors who had actually been denied tenure, they were not much less happy than those who got it.3

The same mistake hides behind our fear of loss. Most people will turn down a coin flip where they could lose $100 unless they stand to win about $200 or more; a loss simply feels bigger than a gain of the same size.4 But when Gilbert’s group actually ran small bets like this, the people who lost money felt much less bad than they had predicted. Part of what we call loss aversion, it seems, is not the pain of losing itself but our exaggerated forecast of it.5

Something similar shows up on the Olympic podium. Researchers found that bronze medalists often look happier than silver medalists. The silver medalist is staring at the gold they almost had. The bronze medalist is thinking about how close they came to no medal at all. Same podium, different imagined alternative.6

Maybe that is the real cost of endlessly weighing paths. It isn’t only the time it takes. It’s that the imagined life quietly steals the joy from the real one.

What medicine taught me about deciding

In the hospital, I make decisions under uncertainty every day. A patient comes in, the picture is incomplete, and I still have to choose a plan. A very common example for an inpatient clinician like me is a patient who comes in with unexplained shortness of breath. At first, I don’t know whether it is pneumonia, a blood clot in the lung, heart failure or a metabolic derangement. Even without the exact answer, I start treatment based on the best available information from the history, the physical exam and quick bedside tests, while we obtain a more comprehensive panel of tests to reach an accurate diagnosis. Then I revise the plan as new information becomes available.

What I have learned is that good clinical judgment isn’t about finding the perfect answer before acting. It’s about choosing carefully, committing fully, and watching closely.

If new information comes in, a lab result or a change on exam, I change course. That isn’t weakness; that’s the job. But I don’t spend the night relitigating every admission, imagining the version where I ordered a different test first. A doctor who did that would be exhausted and, I suspect, worse at medicine.

Life seems to ask for the same posture.

Conviction is not stubbornness

To be clear, owning a choice doesn’t mean staying in something that is hurting you. Some paths really do deserve to be left.

The difference, as I see it, is in why we are reconsidering. If something has actually changed (new information, real harm, a conflict with what we value), then revisiting a choice is wisdom. But if nothing has changed except that our imagination produced another, shinier version of life, that is the trap. One is updating. The other is just restlessness.

So perhaps the wisest thing we can do is not to spend today’s time and calm weighing lives we won’t live, but to choose a path carefully, with conviction, then own it, live it fully, and give our best to the life we are in now.

A layer beyond our control

As we discussed in Grooves, Not Blank Pages, there is perhaps a layer beyond our control in every choice we make: our genes, where and when we were born, the strangers whose choices brush against ours. If that is true, it changes how we should hold our regrets. The path we are on was never entirely our doing. So the paths we didn’t take were never entirely ours to lose.

Long before any of this research, the Bhagavad Gita offered two ideas I keep coming back to. One: we have a right to our actions, but not to their fruits (2.47). Two: it is better to walk one’s own path imperfectly than another’s path perfectly (3.35).7

I read both, in part, as advice about this exact problem. Give your best to the path you are on. Let go of the scoreboard. And stop measuring your life against lives that were never yours.

There are countless lives we might have lived. Only one we ever will.

So here is the question I’m left with: which of the lives you didn’t live are you still paying rent on?

More about who's writing this is on the About page. If this got you thinking, or you'd push back on any of it, I'd genuinely love to hear it: sharma.rujjwal [at] gmail [dot] com. Want a note when something new goes up? Say so in your email and I'll add you to the list.